Justus For All

None Sine Causa

Police Battle Lawyers in Pakistan

7:12 am on Monday, November 5, 2007

New York Times

Police armed with tear gas and clubs attacked thousands of protesting lawyers in the city of Lahore today, and rounded up lawyers in other cities as the government of the Pakistani president, Gen. Pervez Musharraf, faced the first signs of concerted resistance to the imposition of emergency rule.

An estimated 150 lawyers were arrested in Lahore after a pitched battle between police and lawyers who stood on the roof of the High Court throwing stones at the police below. Some of the lawyers had bleeding heads as they were shoved into police vans, and some fainted in the clouds of tear gas.In Multan, another city in the province of Punjab, two new judges who had taken the oath of office under emergency rule Sunday were forced to leave the courtroom after hundreds of lawyers threatened to throw eggs at them.

“We threatened them saying: ‘You’ve taken an unconstitutional oath, if you don’t go we will throw eggs at you.’ They left,” said a lawyer from Multan, Riaz Gilani.

Things in Pakistan are clearly going from bad to worse.  This is a case of only really bad options.  Musharraf is clearly moving further from Democratic reforms and at the same time Al-Qaida and Taliban forces are conducting a very effective insurgency against the nation.  At stake of course is Pakistan’s nuclear weapons, which cannot be allowed in extremist hands.

I am not sure what the best thing for the international community to do is.   Supporting Musharraf is impossible given where he is going, and would likely backfire even if we decided that he was an SOB we could live with.  At the same time, should his move to consolidate power and defeat the Taliban forces through harsh measures fail, we have an absolutely horrific situation.

2 Comments »

Comment by honestpartisan

November 6, 2007 @ 6:24 am

I would disagree with your premise that Musharraf has made a “move to consolidate power and defeat the Taliban.” Musharraf actively supported the Taliban before 9/11, and passively did so afterward. This move of his seems to be directed against secularists in Pakistan who want democracy.

Comment by Dave Justus

November 6, 2007 @ 7:25 am

Perhaps using the Taliban as an excuse to consolidate power would be a better term, although given that they have tried to kill him several times, I don’t think he has a lot of common ground with the Taliban and Al-Qaida at this point.

Pakistan’s alliance with the Taliban before 9-11 was, in my opinion anyway, more about real-politik then an ideological decision, at least on Musharraf’s side, although many members of his government, especially the ISI had different motives. Pakistan was friends with Taliban Afghanistan to block Iranian ambitions in the region as much as anything else.

And of course Musharraf is himself a ’secular’ leader. Musharraf is desperate to restore security in Pakistan and turn the tide against a Taliban insurgency that is gaining strength. He also of course wants to hold on to power, and I expect in his mind anyway the later is a means to the former.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>